Blog Layout
Mastering Academic Feedback on Writing: Strategies for Teachers and Students
Providing effective academic feedback on writing is one of the most impactful ways educators can support student growth. Research and experience consistently show that timely, meaningful feedback clarifies expectations and helps students develop critical skills for success in writing and beyond. Whether you’re following evaluation rubrics like TEAM or preparing students for AP Language standards or EOC writing tests, creating a system for giving and receiving feedback is essential. In this post, I’ll summarize five key strategies to make academic feedback a game-changer in your classroom.
1. What Academic Feedback Is Not
Before mastering academic feedback, it’s important to identify common pitfalls.
- Not vague or generic: Comments like “Good job” or “Needs work” don’t provide actionable insights.
- Not overly critical: Focusing solely on weaknesses can undermine confidence.
- Not a one-time event: Feedback should be an ongoing process that spans the entire writing journey.
2. What Academic Feedback Is
So, what really should it be? Think of academic feedback on writing as a roadmap that leads students toward success, recognizing progress along the way.
- Specific and actionable: Feedback should align with goals, such as rubric criteria or learning objectives. Start small. Picture an isosceles triangle. For example, if I am teaching thesis statements and students write a paragraph, I am going to focus the feedback mostly on the thesis statement in that writing sample. I might also check for a grammar concept we’ve covered that week. This way, students don’t feel overwhelmed with so much red ink on their papers!
- Balanced: Highlight strengths to motivate students and struggles to provide direction. Give a compliment sandwich!
- Integrated: Feedback should guide students from brainstorming to final revision, becoming a natural part of the writing process.
- Timely: Feedback must come when students can act on it. The sooner students receive feedback, the more likely they are to retain and apply it effectively. Timeliness ensures that feedback is relevant to their current work, allowing for immediate improvement. However, teachers often face the challenge of balancing timely feedback with large class sizes and heavy workloads. I get it! Read more on managing the essay grading burden at this post.
3. Teacher-to-Student Feedback
Teacher-given feedback is always the first stop. It’s accurate and reliable. It is the model for all other feedback. Providing effective feedback as a teacher requires a clear process and intentionality.
Why It Matters:
- Builds essential writing skills.
- Clarifies expectations and supports growth.
- Aligns with rubrics like TEAM (for your own evaluations), AP standards, or state writing assessments.
How to Deliver Feedback:
- Focus on specific objectives (e.g., thesis statements in an early draft).
- Gradually expand feedback to include more complex skills.
- Provide feedback in multiple forms: face-to-face, written, or digital.
- Provide a mixture of questions and statements.
- Remember - We aren't editors. Let students know what grammar mistake they made once or twice. They need to do the rest.
Tools for Success:
- AI-powered tools, Google comment banks, or LMS features. Grab my no-prep Tools for Feedback on Writing pack with comments for Google. My comments pack even includes linked videos for automatic and differentiation instruction! Watch me use them here.
- Conference notes or video/audio recordings.
4. Student-to-Student Feedback
Teachers aren’t the only ones who can give feedback! Richard Feynman, a Nobel Prize-winning physicist said, "If you really want to master something, teach it.” Letting students in the driver's seat along the process can produce huge gains for them and their peers. Thus, peer reviews can be very effective in the writing process when done well.
Why It Matters:
- Encourages shared learning and different perspectives.
- Builds students’ evaluative and analytical skills.
- Peer feedback fosters collaboration and critical thinking.
How to Implement It:
- Practice giving feedback on model papers prior to letting students critique each other's papers.
- Emphasize a positive, safe environment for peer critique.
- Use guided questions tied to the rubric to focus feedback. My Tools for Feedback on Writing Pack on Teachers Pay Teachers includes a couple of versions peer review worksheets.
- Provide follow-up time for students to discuss their feedback face-to-face.
5. The Biggest Question: How Do I Get Students to Use Feedback?
I hear you! You spend hours.. days…writing notes, messages, and corrections. Just to have students look at the grade and put the assignment in their notebook - or worse, the trashcan. The only time they have a question is if they can’t read the feedback (anyone else?) or if they don’t agree with something they lost points for. Well, that’s NOT the point. Feedback on writing is only effective if students engage with it.
- Make it part of the process: Build time into class for students to review feedback and ask questions.
- Don't always give a grade: To teach or condition students to see feedback as a tool to become a better writer, I’ve started to remove the number grade in some cases. Maybe I just give a completion grade or no grade at all.
- Encourage reflection: Have students complete self-evaluations to analyze their strengths and areas for improvement.
- Require revisions: Students should submit both original and revised drafts, along with a statement explaining their changes.
- Create class discussions: Identify common themes in strengths and struggles to set shared goals.
- Use student-directed data charts or writing portfolios for students to track progress.
Is It Worth It?
It is a reasonable question. We spend SOOO much time away from class, in class, during planning, etc. So, it's natural to want to know. I can say that actively and consistently providing feedback and teaching students how to engage with it and edit using us it does produce positive results.
Effective academic feedback isn’t just about improving a single piece of writing—it’s about teaching students how to think critically, reflect, and grow as learners. Whether it’s teacher-to-student feedback, peer collaboration, or building a system that ensures students engage with feedback, these strategies create a classroom environment where writing becomes a process of discovery and success. With tools like rubrics, structured feedback methods, and intentional reflection, you’ll empower your students to tackle any writing challenge confidently.
Love this content?
Sign up for my email newsletter with more tips, ideas, success stories, and freebies!
There are those times when "teachering" just isn’t optimal. What do I mean by that? "Teachering," as defined by me, involves delivering new material, expecting students to produce immediate results, or spending the entire class in direct instruction when students are already overloaded or overstimulated. These times include—but are not limited to—the days before a break, the holiday season, the week of a full moon, half days, or even the day after Halloween. During these moments, the best approach is to shift the focus away from you and onto your students. Let them lead, apply what they’ve already learned, reflect on their progress, and take ownership of their work. This hands-off teaching strategy creates a structured yet low-stress classroom environment where students stay calm, focused, and productive.
It’s a unique situation for both parties of a student-teaching experience: on the one hand from the point of view of the student teacher, you are entering someone else’s classroom and you may be teaching solo for the first time, and on the other hand, you may be the classroom teacher who is welcoming someone else into your classroom to take the lead. To say the least, this is a tricky space to navigate. That’s why I thought it would be interesting to speak directly to a student teacher – to hear her thoughts and experiences. Whether you are a cooperating/mentoring teacher of a student teacher or you are a student teacher heading into the classroom, this interview with a student teacher of high school English (Miss M), who just completed her placement, is very enlightening.
You’ve worked hard for half a year or longer to create this beautiful time capsule — the yearbook. You’ve sold advertisements, taken pictures, written headlines and captions, and included as many students as possible. BUT — what if no one sees what you and your staffers have created? That may be a little hyperbolic, but it is super important to have a strategy in place not just for creating the yearbook but for selling it as well. Here’s everything you need to know about how to sell the yearbook!
Our yearbook staff’s motto is “Everybody’s Story. Everybody’s Book.” That means everyone! Not just the seniors, the athletes, the staffers and their friends, certain cliques – everybody. Why does that matter? For one, if we are creating a book for people to purchase, they need to be reflected in it; or they won’t purchase it. But the bigger, more important reason is simply that we are telling the story of a year, and without every person represented, considered, and included in the yearbook design, we haven’t done our job: We haven’t told the true story of the year at all if we let bias or favoritism creep in or if we get lazy with coverage and choices. The yearbook must be an accurate time capsule with reflections of each person’s interests, styles, talents, abilities, and backgrounds. Therefore, you can make your yearbook more diverse and inclusive with these easy steps! Tips for your yearbook pages and beyond.
You’ve just been assigned the yearbook, or last year didn’t go so well, and you want your first days plans to be solid, effective, and fun! Does this sound like you? I’ve been there. The first week of school is a whirlwind, but in yearbook class, the first week back to school is even more topsy turvy, to say the least. You might have looked through my Tips for New Advisers post or How to Have a Picture-Perfect Start to the Year posts for adviser-facing suggestions, and you feel good-to-go from that side of things. However, now it’s time to decide what to do when students are walking through the door — AKA planning the first week of yearbook class! When I think about what to do the first week of school in my yearbook class, I try to think of it like one my English classes in some ways, and in other ways, it is completely different! In this blog post, I’ll share my student-facing plans for the first week of yearbook class.
The 2020-2021 school year was the year of the unexpected, the year of changes, the year of disappointments, the year of frustrations, and certainly the year of loss. It goes down in my book as the hardest year of my teaching career — that includes the first year I taught in middle school, the first year I was a lead in an inclusion classroom, the year I taught while building a house, the first year I was the new yearbook adviser, and the year I taught while having multiple surgeries for some serious medical issues. And let’s not forget that I actually contracted COVID-19 THE. FIRST. DAY. BACK of teacher in-service. However, I didn’t quit. I did survive, and I’m going back. That said, I am choosing to look at the positive — shall we say, “COVID Positive” — Bad pun. Anyway, despite all change that occurred this year — schedules, classrooms, assignments, students, and more, there were a few things that I’m thankful that the COVID-19 pandemic did not change about my classroom.
The yearbook is complete, submitted, done. Now what? You have several months of school left, and you aren’t sure how to keep your students on task for the remaining days. Does this sound familiar? With spring delivery or even summer delivery books where students take yearbook/journalism as a class, it’s often difficult — and even daunting — to come up with creative and constructive ways to use that time. As we all know, doing nothing is not an option! In this blog post, I’ll share 5 ways to use class time after the yearbook is complete.
Whether you are teaching via full remote learning, on a hybrid schedule, or blending your in-person classes with virtual classrooms, you’ll need your lesson plans and materials ready for digital classrooms. The good news is — you can re-purpose lesson plans and materials for digital classrooms without reinventing the wheel or making all new activities, worksheets, files, etc. In this blog post, I hope to share some hacks you can use to easily convert, edit, and share what you have from your traditional classroom right into your digital classroom.
In my previous post on the Benefits of Using Paired Texts to Teach Reading, I discuss the advantages of this brain-based teaching method. It’s no secret that offering ways for students to making connections — text to text, text to self, and text to world — is an opportunity to exercise higher order thinking skills. Teaching shouldn’t happen in a vacuum, even though sometimes it does as we stress to move units along the conveyor belt, more acceptably known as pacing guides. Often and unfortunately, we teach one skill and move quickly onto the next. Confession: I don’t teach that way. Everything must build and connect from unit to unit, text to text, and skill to skill. That’s why paring texts is so important, and in this final post in the series, I want to share the practical, actionable ways that I select and use paired texts for teaching reading.
Paired passages or paired texts are texts that are connected in some way. When the Common Core State Standards rolled out years ago, the concept of teaching with paired texts surfaced. At first, English teachers were worried that the demand for more nonfiction and the requirements of CCSS, R.9 would limit the amount of fiction they could teach. Over time, it became evident that pairing texts and teaching students how to “analyze how two or more texts address similar themes or topics in order to build knowledge or to compare the approaches the authors take” (CCSS, R.9) actually has more advantages than disadvantages. Many states are moving away from CSCC (mine included), but the standard of pairing texts is still required. Not only does pairing texts meet this specific standard, but also it allows you to address several others at once. Once I began to see the benefits of paired texts for teaching reading, it stuck. This is one strategy that will be a permanent part of my teaching reading toolbox. In this blog
